Liberal Catholic, An Oxymoron?
I was inspired to search for answers on whether I could simultaneously be a liberal and a Catholic. I have encountered many people who have told me that I cannot call myself Catholic while holding liberal beliefs b/c they don’t jive with Rome. I wanted to know if these people were right b/c their argument did sway me. Of course my search included the blogosphere where I found many blogs by and about liberal Catholics (nice to find these folks). I emailed one of these bloggers, who was kind enough to send me a lengthy reply. Here are some brief excerpts from Joe's email.
Conservative view:
Conservative view:
Baptism leaves an "indelible mark" on the soul - an[] eternal and unchangeable imprint of Christ....Liberal view:
In conservative theology, it is metaphysically impossible to be separated from the Roman Catholic Church except by a formal declaration of excommunication which must be made explicitly using your name by a bishop.
Jesus of the Gospels is always going after the "lost sheep" and the "prodigal son". He eats and drinks with prostitutes, treasonous tax collectors for the foreign occupation, lepers and other outcasts. He is even executed as a criminal with criminals by state authority with sanction from religious leaders. Jesus came to call sinners - not the self righteous.I take Joe’s word for it, he seems very knowledgeable. I will surely research Catholic dogmas as well. So in other words, yes, I can call myself Catholic and a liberal. And neither the Church nor anyone else can tell me otherwise.